Halo 3: X3F review

It's not often that we here at X3F get a chance to review a high profile title like Halo 3 before it hits store shelves, and it's an opportunity I'm not taking lightly. I've spent the last 48 hours (give or take a few hours for the requisite food and sleep) embedded deep within Halo 3, doing my best to categorize the experience as I went along. In this endeavor I have more or less failed. That's not to say I didn't enjoy what I played, because I absolutely did. It's just that with as many features as there are in Halo 3, there's so much stuff to test that 48 hours really isn't enough time to glean enough information and condense it into a review. Still, review it we must. Read on for a (hopefully) defining glimpse into Microsoft's great green hope.
Gallery: Halo 3
First and foremost on any Halo fan's mind is the campaign. Even fans admit that Halo 2's campaign didn't quite get the attention it deserved. Even beyond the cliffhanger ending and the divisive inclusion of the Arbiter as a playable character -- which, for the record, I loved -- the campaign just didn't seem quite finished. So, Halo 3 has a lot to answer for. I won't spoil the story, but Halo 3 picks up exactly where Halo 2 left off: Cortana (the Master Chief's AI) is missing, the Prophet of Truth is leading an attack on earth, and the Master Chief is rocketing towards the planet on an ancient Forerunner ship. Again, we had to rush through it a bit to get it finished, but by the time the game draws to a close, all loose ends have been tied and questions answered. Old friends and enemies are reunited, alliances formed and broken, and plots are twisted. It's the stuff you'd expect in the closing chapter of a trilogy, with a few special tidbits thrown in for dedicated fans. Also, for those that are interested, locating the secret terminals throughout the game fleshes out the story of the Forerunners and the first firing of the Halo rings. The terminals are optional though, so if you're more interested in blasting baddies, feel free.
But how does it play, you ask? I plowed through the campaign on Heroic (with a few snippets of 4-player co-op on Legendary), and I can assuredly tell you that enemy AI is much improved, and sometimes a little scary. Brutes, ape-like monstrosities introduced in Halo 2, are definitely not the bullet sponges they used to be. This time around they are smart, mean, and, appropriately enough, brutal. One of their most fascinating behaviors is how they use equipment to their advantage. More than once, I found myself launching ordinance towards a pack of Brutes only to see one of them deploy a bubble shield before my shot had landed, rendering it useless. Oh, and watch out for Brutes with gravity hammers. They tend to carry equipment that makes them invulnerable for a few seconds. An invulnerable Brute with a gravity hammer is the stuff of nightmares.

Don't think that the Brutes are the star of the show though, every enemy, in one way or another, can be pretty terrifying. You see, not only are enemies smart, but they use sound tactical thinking. So, if you clear out a pack of Brutes and Grunts, don't celebrate right away, because there's a very good chance you're about to be sniped by a Jackal that you overlooked. Hell, even a pair of Jackals with carbines can be a pain, especially if you thought it would be a good idea to pack a short-range arsenal. And yes, believe it or not, even Grunts can put you away if you're not careful. Oh, and remember what I said about Brutes and nightmares? There is one Grunt behavior that's worse. I'll leave you to discover what exactly the behavior is, but rest assured you'll know it when you see it.
And then there's the Flood, the body-snatching enemy that's threatening to devour all life in the galaxy, Covenant and human alike. Now, I'm not saying one thing about the Flood. Nothing. You play. You find out. I'll just say this ain't your Granddaddy's Flood and leave it at that.

Honestly, my biggest complaint about the campaign is that it's over too quickly. It's not like the game has a bad ending, far from it, but I wanted more. Don't misunderstand, the game isn't too short, I just didn't want it to end.
Fortunately, the campaign is far from the end. This time around Bungie has included plenty of incentive to go back through the campaign multiple times. Of course there is online co-op, but there are also skulls to be found, campaign scoring achievements to be earned, as well as finding terminals you may have missed. Campaign, to put it simply, has been done right. Now, let's look at everything else.

Unfortunately, online matchmaking wasn't activated at the time of this review, but I did get to mess around with some local multiplayer. Those who participated in the beta have a good idea of what to expect. More or less, Halo 3's multiplayer is a refinement of the multiplayer in Halo 2. Certain things have been tweaked, most notably the re-invention of the assault rifle. Given a decent starting weapon, multiplayer is no longer about a mad dash for a better weapon the second you spawn. Sure, there are great weapons to find, but the assault rifle is a competent weapon in most situations. Another addition is the ability to edit all kinds of traits in the game. Traits can be given to all players or the team / player in the lead. How you use this is up to you. Want to boost everyone's shields, increase running speed, reduce gravity, and give everyone a gravity hammer and a Spartan laser? Go for it (it's pretty fun, actually). Multiplayer is now (literally) what you make of it, and it's a blast.

Now, if you really want to control how a game plays out, there's the Forge. Succinctly, Forge is some of the stupidest fun you can have with a game. At least, that's what it is at first. Forge allows players to create map variants by placing, deleting, and editing objects. These objects include simple things like scenery, weapons, and vehicles, but you can also edit more complex things like spawn points and CTF capture points. Inevitably though, your first instinct will be to find a flat surface, pile it with fusion coils, and launch a Mongoose to the moon. Follow that instinct. Follow it hard. You won't be disappointed. In fact, why not cue up the film of my first attempt right now? No, really, you can click here, find the movie titled "Boomtastic-X3F", click "Download to Halo 3", and once you pop Halo 3 into your 360, it will begin downloading automatically.

And that brings us to saved films. Basically, every game of Halo 3 you play, be it campaign, multiplayer, or Forge, is automatically saved as a film. Once you wrap up a game, simply head into the theater lobby and load it up. The game caches your recent sessions, but you'll have to manually save them if you want them permanently. During a saved film, players have complete control over the camera, allowing them to frame the best view of the action. If you see a particularly cool piece of action, you can record it as a smaller clip. Also, players can take static screenshots of the action on screen. In fact, every screenshot in this review was taken in game using the saved film feature.
And that, as briefly as I can put it, is Halo 3. Honestly, as long as this review is, it's really not long enough. Regardless of how players receive the story's conclusion, the amount of content contained in the Halo 3 package is just staggering. With campaign co-op, multiplayer, Forge, and saved films, the game offers plenty of bang for your gaming buck. Many will claim that it's not as pretty as Gears of War, and arguably they'd be right, but it was never meant to be.
I never intended to write a review filled with nothing but praise for Halo 3, but it's just damned hard to criticize. Sure, there are things I could point out that are disappointing. The graphics aren't perfect. You can't save clips in campaign. The story will be confusing to newcomers. Yeah, I can pick nits all day if I wanted to, and doubtless many Halo detractors will do just that, but the game is good. The conflicts are huge, the levels are vast, and the gameplay is solid. Not only that, but the extras ensure that players will still be playing Halo 3 for a long time to come. Love it or hate it, Halo is back on top, and it's probably there to stay.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
JakenBear @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:09PM
Well written review Richard. I can't wait to pick up my Cat Helmet edition (will modify to fit my dog) monday at midnight.
David @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:10PM
Amen to your closing comments.
ruuitazura4 @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:11PM
too excited for words
DocParanoia @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:11PM
I love that you didn't spoil anything in this review. Thank you.
kHz Glitch @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:13PM
Nice review :)
Kirbdaddy @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:17PM
Thanks for the great review. Did MS send you the big swag bag they sent to reviewers on other sites???
MYPS3KilledMy360 @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:26PM
i heard the run through of the game on just normal is only 8 hours and thats with tons of respawns at checkpoints.
vanhelsingh @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:26PM
I knew I could trust X3F to not put any spoilers in the review.
Rk @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:33PM
I *AM* looking forward to Halo 3 multiplayer - but when the last week of October rolls around, I'm afraid Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 is going to take my attention away from Halo, my girlfriend and and prospects of employment.
Little Lee @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:33PM
Aww Flood. Theres me they would drop that shit.
Good review though Rich
Knight Marquise @ Sep 23rd 2007 4:33PM
Damn fine/professional review Richard, but I'd expect nothing less from you.
Alijah Green @ Sep 23rd 2007 5:08PM
I think Halo 3 looks better then gear given the scale of their campaign
DaMan09 @ Sep 23rd 2007 5:09PM
Great review Richard
Kyle @ Sep 23rd 2007 5:11PM
arghhhhhh please tell me what this is all about im dying to know!!
"Oh, and remember what I said about Brutes and nightmares? There is one Grunt behavior that's worse. I'll leave you to discover what exactly the behavior is, but rest assured you'll know it when you see it."
email me if u dont want to "spoil it" for other ppl :)
thanksss
Homer 918 @ Sep 23rd 2007 5:11PM
I thought that was an exceptionally well written review, great job.
Matt McClard @ Sep 23rd 2007 5:47PM
great review, I have always thought you guys should do more reviews. Also I love the way there is no stupid number, thanks and keep up the awesomeness!
Project Ekim @ Sep 23rd 2007 5:58PM
i Know what the grunt does thats even worse if you dont want to know dont read on..
they hold to plasmas in there hands activate them and run like hell towards you believe me its not a good feeling seeing an overly determined grunt doing that.
jose_edwaldo @ Sep 23rd 2007 6:00PM
Nice review. Never been a major Halo fan, I played the first one for a little while, but never finished it, and I never even touched Halo 2, but for some reason I'm getting super-pumped for this game. Should have my limited edition tomorrow.
DjDATZ @ Sep 23rd 2007 6:02PM
Awesome review Rich! :D 28 hours to go! :D
a.j. @ Sep 23rd 2007 6:11PM
i've had it since Friday, great game.
erivera3 @ Sep 23rd 2007 6:19PM
Great review, wish other reviewers understood how great this game was too instead of giving it anything less than perfect; makes me sad when I see just how much this game has to offer, but it is their opinions in the end so I guess I can't fault them for that.
BrianM @ Sep 23rd 2007 6:49PM
Thank you for the review :)
Hobo Joe @ Sep 23rd 2007 7:14PM
This campaign had better be great-ish. It's the only reason I play these damn games in the first place.
Yeah yeah, "you're missing the point," whatever. I don't do online multiplayer, and everyone knows I don't have any real friends.
ToRro2 @ Sep 23rd 2007 8:18PM
Nice review, I think Ill live up to the hype this time around.
lachlan @ Sep 23rd 2007 8:30PM
am i the only person who isn't going to buy halo 3? i might buy it for half price but there's no way i'm picking this up at launch.
give me mass effect dammit!
Triforceowner @ Sep 23rd 2007 8:55PM
It's so pretty...
Murcury @ Sep 23rd 2007 8:59PM
Excellent review! Being a daily (Multiple times a day) viewer, I knew going into the review that I wouldn't have to worry about spoilers. With that said; this is the only review I'll read before playing! Thank you and I request an Encore!
Jay @ Sep 23rd 2007 9:02PM
@Lachlan
Yes, yes you are.
johnathon @ Sep 23rd 2007 9:14PM
thank you for not posting any spoilers.
had to put my xbox in pawn yesterday, so I'm skipping my preorder of halo 3 :'(
so its with a smile that I avoid spoilers from both you and Ign.
[goes to rob old ladies and banks before tuesday]
Dorv @ Sep 23rd 2007 9:18PM
@lachlan: Not really. I'm sitting here waiting for the Orange Box, and wondering how the Halo launch will affect the Gears community. My hope is that it pulls away all of the glitching whiny kids ;)
waffle111 @ Sep 23rd 2007 9:24PM
lol check this out guys halo3 got high lol
http://youtube.com/watch?v=bqVxKpPVBPc
Towdart @ Sep 23rd 2007 10:26PM
Very solid review. Can't wait to play it at my friend's house Tuesday at midnight.
erivera3 @ Sep 23rd 2007 11:19PM
@30
People still play Gears of War? Interesting, it got old for me after I realized I was playing the same maps with 4v4 max and basically only playing variations of team slayer with no vehicular combat or customization whatsoever.
Jelly Jedi @ Sep 23rd 2007 11:55PM
I really enjoyed this review. I read IGN's and Gamespot's and so far I think this one is the best. Awesome job!
Crimson @ Sep 24th 2007 1:20AM
That was a great review. Well written, good article overall. Looking back on all the great times I've had with Halo, I can't help but get sentimental. I remember the first Halo party I went to, it was amazingly fun and awesome. Then Halo 2 came around and parties got even better. The best I could do for people was eight, that was as large as it got. Now....now....how things have changed.
I just had a seven hour Halo LAN in my basement......14....14 people....13 people to slaughter.....6 teammates whose asses need saved....Zombiez, Border Patrol, Zombiez Wavez.....Slayer Vanilla, Multi Flag CTF...
It's the first time I've ever maxed out my eight port little hub, the first time I've ever had eight Xbox's all crammed in my basement, 14 dudes + my gf all together having a great time. But seriously, you should see this hub, it's literally electrical taped together, with no lag. Just sometimes people can't join a game, so I restart the hub and rehost and it's all cool for another few hours.
Next weekend we're having a Halo 3 LAN, I can't friggen wait for that! I can't wait to play infection, all that amazing zombie slaying goodness!
I Believe. I really do.
*Don't worry, my girlfriend knows how big of a nerd I am, she actually stopped in on the party for a while. Luckily she's a nerd about stuff too, so she understands completely.*
CalabreZ @ Sep 24th 2007 1:45AM
So does X3F not give scores to the games? What is the rating out of 10!?
Mahmoud @ Sep 24th 2007 1:49AM
nice
Zeus the God @ Sep 24th 2007 2:36AM
@31
Thats Garry's Mod on the CS:S map de_dust2. Its been done a million times with Gman and other games.
Vern @ Sep 24th 2007 5:21AM
well written review, i must say though every game has it's flaws i guess right??? and halo isn't meant to be this crazy graphical game in my opinion. I think that the gameplay is what really counts regardless how the game looks...n o one likes gears becoause it's pretty they love the intense action they love. Btw nice way to end the review.
MARKTW @ Sep 24th 2007 7:07AM
Fusion Coils Rule!
CanesTim @ Sep 24th 2007 8:49AM
Good review. It's too bad I'll be out of town this Thursday to Monday so I'll only get a few days play. Probably won't get to finish the campaign till the following week which sucks since I am more about the campaign than multiplayer.
JoshGomez @ Sep 24th 2007 9:45AM
Halo is a good game but they forgot one thing, I think. There is no gunshot decals and/or blood decals on player models. But I guess they can fix this with a game update. This is a must for movie makers with halo 3... I only think the decals should appear when the user have 0% shield.
ANt @ Sep 24th 2007 10:15AM
They said the A.I. is suspect at times, namely your Co Op partner.
klitchls @ Sep 24th 2007 10:27AM
Amen! I can't wait to play it tomorrow...
captain underpants and the bringdown gang @ Sep 24th 2007 10:27AM
what I want to do is watch that video without having a xbox 360 or halo 3. teasing us like that is only going to make us mad...or beg for mercy depending on weather or not you bow to our demands.
embleau @ Sep 24th 2007 10:39AM
I'm totally unimpressed with the Halo series. It's a subpar FPS. I've grown with all the FPS on the PC. Halo has NOTHING original including it's story (Aliens attacking Earth). Want something new and exciting? Play Bioshock.
renatox @ Sep 24th 2007 10:58AM
FUCK i hope this everyday halo BULL SHIT stops when the stupid game comes out!!!
Digitalspirit @ Sep 24th 2007 11:09AM
Ima go pleh halo 3 retail
NickyB DYB @ Sep 24th 2007 11:14AM
just completed it and i totaly agree with the review you guys are in for a treat
erivera3 @ Sep 24th 2007 12:28PM
lol @ 46 and 47
Why bother even posting here, just move along.