Ask X3F: the first edition

Welcome to the very first installment of Ask X3F, where our readers can send their burning questions our way. For our first edition, we talk about switching Live IDs, what to expect from the Red Ring of Death, rigging an SATA hard drive to work on a 360, MMOs, and which breed of dog is best for gamers (no, seriously). Find your questions and our answers after the break. If you've got a question to ask, or just something you want to share with us, send your emails to: ask [at] xbox360fanboy [dawt] com.
Hi guys,
Do you know why the Inside Xbox newsfeed-type feature introduced in the Fall Update is not available outside the US? Well, it's not here in New Zealand (and elsewhere I've read) but isn't it just a feed of what's new and community vids? From what I've seen it's hardly USA-inclined content ... not sure how it's deemed irrelevant to gamers outside the States and I think a lot of people feel like they're not getting 100% of XBL features (but we pay as much as you do for the service) - any ideas?
Cheers,
Andrew (Auckand, New Zealand)
Gamertag: Halwende
PS: Keep up the good work, love the site & fancast!
We don't know the official reason for the delay in rolling out the Inside Xbox service, but our guess is that Microsoft is waiting to produce localized content for each region. We do know, however, that it is coming to other regions over time. We have a feeling, however, that it might take longer for New Zealand to get it than, say, Canada. Don't worry about it though, you're not missing much thus far.
Well, you asked for questions, so here's something the came up last night that I couldn't get confirmation on. If I connect an external USB drive to my 360, what can I actually put on it? I was able to confirm that it had to be FAT32 formatted and I could access movies and files off of it - but the important question is can I use it to save DLC and demos and marketplace videos. I've got one of those dinky 20 GB drives and I'm constantly having to prune back my files. A 120 GB drive for the 360 costs a whopping $150-170 and I've got a bunch of external hard drives laying around that I'd love to re-purpose.
I'm assuming that Microsoft wouldn't sell their bigger drive for so much if I could just use anything - but short of connecting it and trying myself, I wasn't able to find any confirmation online about what functionality you're able to get out of an external drive.
If you could clarify the whole situation, that'd be great.
Thanks,
Derek
The short answer is that you cannot put game related data on an external USB hard drive. Officially, the only use for external hard drives is for media content. If, however, you are particularly industrious, you can modify certain SATA hard drives to function with the 360. Essentially, you trick the 360 into thinking the SATA HDD is an official Microsoft drive. You'll still be restricted to a maximum of 120GB, but a normal 120GB drive can be had for much less than Microsoft's. If you'd like more info about how to modify a drive for this purpose, you can check this post. FYI, modifying anything related to your Xbox is something you do at your own risk and may void your 360 warranty.
Hey I was wondering what ever happened to the ability to change the Live ID linked to my gamertag. I remember when the update first came out Microsoft said not to change cause of some bug. Has that been fixed?
Philip
Gamertag: Gob 8luth
Yes, the problem has been fixed. For those unaware, the issue to which Philip is referring caused gamers to lose profile information from their Xbox.com forum profiles when changing the Live ID associated with their gamertag. This problem has since been fixed, and you can now change the Live ID associated with your gamertag without fear. Check this post on Major Nelson's blog for more info.
Dear X3F,
1) Where is Fanboy Towers? Also, may we see some pictures of it?
2) Since you guys are always online letting us fanboys join your games and all, why not just have more fanboy gaming events so that the games are more eventful and populated?
3) I'm adopting a new dog from the animal shelter soon, what breed has been known for its gaming abilities?
Sincerely,
zourskittles
1) Fanboy Towers is everywhere, and yet they are nowhere. Assuming you can successfully invent a transdimensional camera, then yes, you may see some pictures of it. By the way, should you invent such a device, know that the concept was created by us, and you will be required to share any profits gained as a result.
2) This usually boils down to scheduling. It's hard to get everyone on board at the same time. It can also be difficult to find a game that we all have and supports a large number of players. We may begin holding X3F Live events at more regular intervals, say once a month or so.
3) We're not sure about gaming abilities, but we recommend the noble Beagle. They are cuddly, well-behaved, and, most importantly, adorable.
I recently got the Red Ring of Death after 2 years...I thought I would have been in the clear by now. When I get my Xbox back, will it be the same xbox, a new xbox, or a different refurbished xbox? Will It just have bigger heat sinks or will it have the new 65nm chip? Once it is fixed, what is the likelihood that I'll get the RROD again? (let's assume that I keep it well ventilated)
--
Regards,
Steven H Roemerman Sr
Based on our personal experiences and the experiences of coworkers, you're most likely going to receive a refurbished console. It will also likely include the new heat sink. Unless you do get a brand new box, you probably won't get the 65nm chips, either. As for the chance it will RROD again, it's anyone's guess. We're pretty sure that Microsoft has a handle on the repair process now, and the heat sinks seem to be doing their job. Anyone out there who have had a 360 replaced, feel free to share your own story with Steven in the comments. Best of luck, Steven!
i was wondering if you guys knew anything about the original arcade version of Killer Instinct ever being released on 360, I downloaded the rare picture pack back at launch and there is a gamer picture of Fulgore straight out of the original game, so if they can sell the picture, they can sell the game, then right???
We don't know anything super secret, no. However, there was a recent round of speculation that a third installment of Killer Instinct might be on the way. You may have seen the Rare Christmas card that's been circulating the net. Take a close look at the stockings on the mantle in the image, and you'll see that one of them reads "KI3." Take it for what you will, but we might be in for something a little more exciting than an XBLA game.
Will there ever be an MMORPG for the 360?
Actually, there are already some available. Final Fantasy XI is currently the only persistent world MMO available. There is also a dungeon crawler MMOs available in Phantasy Star Universe. It's what some people consider traditional MMOs, as it doesn't feature a persistent world, but it does feature a hub area where players can congregate, trade, and build questing parties. Other similar games that are coming soon include Too Human and Sacred 2. For the record, both Final Fantasy XI and Phantasy Star Universe require a monthly fee to play (they both recently received expansions too). Also, with the recent creation of Activision Blizzard we can almost guarantee you that someone in those gilded halls is trying to figure out how to get an iteration of World of Warcraft (or a new game entirely) into the lucrative console market (though they deny there are any plans to do so right now).
And that's it for the first installment of Ask X3F. We'll be back next Tuesday with more questions and answers, so keep 'em coming.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Jeramy @ Dec 25th 2007 9:12PM
when i sent in my rrod console, i got the same one back (i know b/c the dlc still works offline) but with a different mac adress, for some reason. plus i still have the shiny detailing on the top (vertical) of the console (anyone who has a recent console or controler will notice that the detailing is gray and not shiny silver like on the original ones)
David W. @ Dec 25th 2007 9:28PM
I got a refurb and my DLC still worked fine...I would be shocked if you actually got your console back.
OBM @ Dec 25th 2007 9:31PM
Download content is on the hard disk :S
Anyway, new MAC address will normally = new console. I can't see MS messing about fixed the heat sink then changing the network controller just for the fun of it.
DjDATZ @ Dec 25th 2007 11:09PM
OBM...don't know if you know this, but DLC when it is downloaded for the first time is "tied" to the current console you have. This is a form of DRM (Digital Rights Management) that helps protect DLC from being used on another console without the original-downloading-gamertag being present on that storage medium on that console.
Now, onto what these guys are talking about. Usually, when you send your console off to Microsoft to get repaired, you, in most cases, get a refurbished unit that is not yours. The biggest problem with this is that the serial number is different and that DLC cannot be used in full without being signed into Xbox Live. What they are talking about is that they got their own console back, repaired nonetheless, so that their DLC still works offline.
If you have any more questions about this, post up and I'll try to answer.
Dirk Dorkelson @ Dec 26th 2007 4:37AM
My 360 (a launch unit) crashed back in April. I actually got my original unit back (I wrote down the serial number before I sent it in.) It was only gone for a total of three weeks, so whatever they did to fix it, they were able to accomplish it quickly.
xenocidic @ Dec 26th 2007 10:28AM
best way to check - compare the serial number of the unit you got back to the one you sent in.
lharmon @ Dec 26th 2007 12:51PM
The serial number is on the case, I was reading on the forums that some folks said the cases are being gutted, and just replaced with working parts (temporarily working that is). That would give you the same serial number, but with changed info or DRM issues.
CyberKnight @ Dec 26th 2007 10:50PM
When I got mine repaired, they sent back a refurbished unit (I believe it was actually slightly older than my previous console). However, they also transferred the DLC licenses to the new console. All of the content that I purchased on the old console, my kids could still play the full versions of those games without me having to sign in. So, they *can* transfer that when they replace your console. (I've heard incidental reports of that not working for some people, so even though they *can*, they don't always *do*.)
Now, this was when console #2 was replaced by Microsoft with console #3. My first console died after the original 3-month warranty but before Microsoft extended warranties, so I exchanged it with a Best Buy replacement plan. Purchases I made on *that* console, after the swap (Best Buy let me keep my hard drive), my kids couldn't play without me being signed in on console #2 -- and that hasn't changed with console #3.
Scott Ores @ Dec 25th 2007 10:58PM
hey for anyone that has sent their console in are they sending back consoles with the hdmi port back or are they without?
DjDATZ @ Dec 25th 2007 11:15PM
You shouldn't be expecting it to come back with an HDMI port. They still have the older refurbished units. Only about 2 months ago did the various teams start producing the Falcon chipsets as standard. So you probably won't see the HDMI ports poppin up as returns from the repair depot till, I'm gonna take a wild stab at this, and say May-ish 2008?
colin @ Dec 26th 2007 4:06AM
i just got mine back monday, no hdmi. but it was a speedy turnaround. 10 (total) days there and back.
Jim Ray, aka JadeDr4g0n @ Dec 25th 2007 11:15PM
I got a launch day conole, and 7 mos later, rrod visited me. They sent me what they called a new console, probably a refurb, which rrod'd 10 mos later, and when I called about that one, they basically told me the warranty was over and I would have to pay 125 to fix it. This was after the warranty was extended from Microsoft. Many attempts to get some help on this problem were met with much attitude and rudeness on MS Tech Support side, everyone else I've tried to talk to has been no help whatsoever. I ended up buying a preowned 360 from Gamestop when you could get the extended warranty from them... but they've stopped that program for the 360... My prayers are with you steven...
Peff @ Dec 25th 2007 11:18PM
before i sent my xbox in, my faceplate was cracked, and then when i got it back i got a new faceplate, but idk if that means new system, or refurbed, or my original console back with just a new faceplate. so its pretty much anyones guess.
Scott Ores @ Dec 25th 2007 11:26PM
ok i have a question again, so i got a launch day console and just before they announced the extended warrenty my console rrod'd, wanting to save money and knowing a little about electronics i took the console apart and installed my own heat sinks, and the console worked just fine, but recently the console has been freezing alot, so the question is do you think microsoft would take the console back and fix it for me or do you think that i have voided all hopes away?
mergedwarrior @ Dec 26th 2007 1:32AM
You are voided. The Microsoft seal of "Authenticity" has been removed, thus voiding the console.
Nice job on the self heat sink installation. I would just try cleaning the heat sinks (You installed).
Tim @ Dec 26th 2007 1:37AM
To be honest if it takes a turn for the worse I think your screwed...Sorry
xenocidic @ Dec 26th 2007 10:29AM
my friend recently sent in a warranty-void console and got a refurb back no problem.
can't hurt to try.
slearl @ Dec 25th 2007 11:51PM
I am on my fourth console right now. Other than my initial purchase, this one has lasted the longest.
bigedd5000 @ Dec 26th 2007 1:12AM
BEAGLES ROCKKKKKKK
mattclarkie @ Dec 26th 2007 11:20AM
Staffordshire Bull Terrier, the English model, are the best dogs in the world. Mine pwns me at halo Like I am Masterchief in those videos.
colin @ Dec 26th 2007 10:37PM
my chihuahua just sleeps in my lap, keeping my nuts warm.
DjDATZ @ Dec 26th 2007 2:20AM
LOL...I answered 2 of those questions in the Ask X3F announcement post...
Carlsb3rg @ Dec 26th 2007 11:02AM
My question was not mentioned in this edition, will it be mentioned in the next editions or was it deleted?
Jon @ Dec 26th 2007 8:05AM
Boo. answer more.
Richard Mitchell @ Dec 26th 2007 9:36AM
Maybe when it's not on Christmas. Jerk.
Jon @ Dec 26th 2007 11:19AM
Fair enough.
murph @ Dec 26th 2007 9:50AM
Good info to know about the RROD replacements. I'm waiting on a coffin. Thank goodness I have two X360's - otherwise it would be a Rock Band-less New Years Eve and I would be PISSED!!
gonzo @ Dec 26th 2007 10:39AM
My launch unit failed on my after a couple of years of service. They then sent me a refurb unit which had issues staying connected to Live. I sent that in after a week of trying to fix my network at home which wasn't the cause as well as spending a couple of hours with MS Tech Support. Then the 3rd unit came and it has worked great for 4-5 months. Then it suddenly started to not read discs etc. Sent that in and hopefully will get a speedy turnaround time given that it was Christmas season et al.
The only time that they gave me issues with the warranty was for my refurb unit not being able to connect to Live. The time that I called regarding my 2nd refurb unit, I didn't get any hassles (which was good)
Arnie @ Dec 26th 2007 11:23AM
I am surpised you guys forgot Age of Conan:Hyborian Adventures??? This has to be the most anticiapted MMORPG on the Xbox360!!! It could even allow the PC people to join up with the Xbox360 to collectively kick arse.
Also, its highly adult theme should stop some kids from getting in at least. Although releasing on the PC first it is confirmed on the 360(at least currently on the official website).
A follow up question for the MMORPG question would be do you need Live GOLD to play these games and still pay a monthly subscription? If thats the case its a serious rip-off.
Urza @ Dec 26th 2007 12:28PM
If you want a 65nm chip and HDMI the best thing you can do is put your refurbished 360 on ebay and go out an buy an Arcade. Obviously you're going to pay a little more, but at least it's a new box with a fresh warranty.
zlionsfan @ Dec 26th 2007 1:36PM
One thing about that is if you got a refurbished one back instead of getting your original one repaired, then you're already dealing with the offline DRM thing (not being able to play XBLA games you bought on the other console unless you can connect to Xbox Live), so you'd be in the same boat with respect to a new Arcade model. (I've actually considered the same thing for the same reason.)
I didn't get a RROD, but did have other issues under warranty. I got a refurbished one back and haven't had any problems with it: it even recognizes my camera (the other one didn't).
David @ Dec 26th 2007 1:37PM
Has anyone tried ripping an HD DVD to a 120GB external HDD(fat32 formatted) and then plugging that into there xbox to see if it plays?
Stephen @ Dec 26th 2007 6:07PM
@ zourskittles
Don't get a beagle!!!! They bark...a lot!!!! Get a run of the mill mutt.
zourskittles @ Dec 27th 2007 5:05PM
Its okay we didn't get a beagle, we used to have one but that thing was psycho and you can't train beagles very well. Thanks though
Stephen @ Dec 28th 2007 4:33PM
What did you end up getting? Myself I have an Akita/pitbull mix and she's perfect for gaming. Quiet, sleeps most of the day. Sometimes she wants affection and nuzzles my hands while I'm playing but it doesn't bother me too much I just indulge her and send her on her way.
SPYDA BOY @ Dec 28th 2007 3:04AM
Do you guys thin Assassins Creed is a good game? please reply
DjDATZ @ Dec 28th 2007 11:59AM
I think it's really good. I played it a bit right when it came out but only did the first assassination... then on christmas eve i thought i'd give myself a treat and threw that back in the drive. been playing pretty much just that since...and i'm lovin it. :D it's a great game!
DjDATZ @ Dec 27th 2007 8:26AM
spam.