Ask X3F: Dreamcast 360 edition

Ask X3F, the recurring feature where we answer our readers' most pressing quandaries, returns once again with a shiny new installment. This week we cover HDTV calibration (as well as we can anyway), 360 hard drive data transferring, Rock Band covers versus master tracks, and we even do our best to spoil Fable 2 for everyone. We also dream of a world in which we could play all of our old Dreamcast games on our Xbox 360. If such a world existed, surely we would call it heaven. Read on for supreme edification.
Got a question for Ask X3F? Maybe you have a story or some information you'd like to share? Send it all to ask [at] xbox360fanboy [dot] com.
Got a question for Ask X3F? Maybe you have a story or some information you'd like to share? Send it all to ask [at] xbox360fanboy [dot] com.
Dear X3F,
How come on games like Rock Band, sometimes the DLC can't be the master tracks? I've never been able to comprehend a logical reason for this so I thought maybe you could help. Thanks.
- Messs17
While we certainly can't speak for Harmonix or MTV Games, it probably boils down to legalities and money. Someone has to pay to license all the tracks used in Rock Band, and there are legal differences between a written song and a recorded performance of a song. The differences between who owns the rights to what (and how much money they want to license them) is trickier than we'd care to detail (assuming we could actually make sense of it all). Suffice it to say that sometimes, for whatever reason, MTV and Harmonix can score the rights to use a song but not the rights to use the original band recording.
I just bought a new HDD and i was wondering if there was anyway to transfer my old saves and themes and stuff from my old HDD to my new?
And if so how do I do it?
Thanks,
Trevor
If you bought the 120GB hard drive, it should have come with a cable to transfer the data from a 20GB hard drive. You should know that this can only be done once, as it will erase the info on your 20GB hard drive after the transfer is complete. If you don't want to do that (or if you bought an additional 20GB hard drive for some reason), you can always use a 360 memory unit to transfer game saves and the like to another hard drive. Considering memory units can only story 512MB, it could take some time if your hard drive is full. Keep in mind that some things, like title updates, can't be transferred to a memory card.
Dear X3F Chimeras,
You are chimeras, right?
Anywho, I have a quick question about the up and coming Fable 2 due to release sometime.. this year hopefully.
I can never get a straight answer, and now I'm all confused with searching the internet for the answer. So I sacrified the lamb you asked for in hopes of the answer.
Question: Does your dog eventually die somewhere within the game's plot? And if so, is there a way to stop it from happening?
Thanks,
Phoenix.
WARNING: We have no way to know if we're actually spoiling Fable 2 -- it's not out yet, you see -- but the following answer contains potential spoilers.
Chimeras? No. We're more like Hooloovoos. Also, leave the lambs alone, unless you plan to eat them and make a sweater. As for your question, we don't have a definite answer but signs definitely point to yes. There was definitely chatter about the topic during E3 2007, though we can't confirm it. We can, however, confirm something James Silva (creator of The Dishwasher: Dead Samurai) told us during GDC 08. When speaking about Fable 2 maestro Peter Molyneux, he told us:
"Well he is going to kill my dog. He told me that, told everyone that. He said, "I'm going to give you a dog, you're going to love it, and then I'm going to take it away."
So, um, you might not want to get to attached to your friendly pooch.
End (potential) spoiler
hay,
ive been seeing all kinds of questions lately about games that have been canceled or not heard about for a long time. one of the launch games i was really looking forward to was frame city killer. a long time ago i think i remember seeing some rumors about it beeing canceled. is that true?
thanks,
eddie (fat santa eater)
Yup. Frame City Killer, once one of the more intriguing titles headed to the 360 back when it was still new, is officially dead. It's been so since May of 2006. It ain't coming back. C'est la vie.
Why doesnt the xbox originals have achievement points? they take the time putting them on the market place but dont add a few achievements in it that could probably double the sales.
Kristian (pronouned like christian)
Gamertag: PWN5TARR
Quick answer: because it's easier this way. Long answer: adding achievements would require futzing with the code for each game headed to Xbox Originals. This, in turn, would require the companies that made the original games to revisit their old code and implement the achievements retroactively, something we're guessing most companies aren't keen to do. As it stands, the games require no changes as they are already backwards compatible. Changing anything would make things more difficult (and possibly screw up backwards compatibility that can already be temperamental).
Hello X3F,
I've been reading your blog non-stop, every time hoping there is new info on NG2. In preparation, I've decided to play through Black again. However, I no longer have my original Xbox, so I'm playing on my X360 in BC mode. This is the first time, so there are no save files on my HDD. To my horror, the only mode available out of the box is normal. I completely forgot that I had to beat the game at normal to unlock anything remotely challenging. So my question is this: are there any cheats that unlock harder difficulties? Of course, if there aren't, then I'll just have to beat the game twice =)
Thanks,
Michael Cooper
Gamertag: NummNutts
Michael, listen up. Ninja Gaiden Black is one of the hardest games released for the last generation of consoles and arguably one of the most difficult games ever made. It was intentionally designed to be so. It even goes so far as to include an easy mode that makes fun of you for selecting it. Now ask yourself again: does this game have cheat codes? No. No it doesn't. Just take comfort in the fact that it's still one of the best playing games of all time and plow through it again. It should get you nice and warmed up for (Game of the Year 2008) Ninja Gaiden II.
Wouldn't it be awesomely spiffy if Sega released a emulator via the market place that would let you play your legally purchased Dreamcast (or Saturn) disks on the 360?
Given that code is out there for computers running windows, it should not take that much effort for Sega to create a nice legal one for the 360.
Awesomely spiffy? Hell, yes. But, we have to ask, why would Sega let gamers play all their old Dreamcast games for free when they could just have them buy them all again on Xbox Live Arcade? Trust us, if Dreamcast games ever wind up on the Xbox 360 it will be the result of Sega re-releasing titles. That is, of course, unless someone can successfully hack a Dreamcast emulator onto an Xbox 360 (so close...).
Hi guys
I recently got myself a spiffy 46" Bravia XBR (1080i) and I noticed when I initially started playing the colors and black was a bit out of whack (was set to 'vivid'), but I managed to tone it down to something acceptable after mucking around with 'standard' for a bit.
Now the other week Lifehacker had an article on HDTV calibration
I don't have any of those utilities at the moment...
I guess what I'm wondering is how people configure their HDTV for optimal Xbox 360 gaming? What are some of the display features that should be turned on for games? Do you recommend any of the calibration DVD's out there?
Regards
PH
If you happen to have the Collector's or Legendary edition of Halo 3, it actually includes an HD calibration tool. We can vouch for its effectiveness, but it's an option if you already have the game. Bungie seemed to think it was good enough that it deserved a special blue filter. If you're planning on using this tool, you can still get blue filters for free from Bungie whenever you make any other purchase.
As for other calibration DVDs, we'll leave that one to the readers to answer. How about it, readers? What calibration DVDs would you recommend?
That's it for this week, folks. Keep sending your questions to: ask [at] xbox360fanboy [dawt] com.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Halwende @ Apr 22nd 2008 6:36PM
For some (really) basic HDTV calibration you could use the THX video tests on the Star Wars DVD's (in the language menu, click the THX logo)
Another tip is download a test picture (Google images), open it on your Xbox and adjust your TV
http://images.pcworld.com/howto/graphics/139156-THX6_b.jpg
Also experiment with the Xbox display setting - flick between "standard" / "extended" etc, I used the intro FMV and first 10 seconds of gameplay in Gears of War as a "black benchmark" because it uses a wide range of darks & light
NOT ME @ Apr 22nd 2008 6:42PM
wow they didnt really answer anything...except the dreamcast question. They should have told him how to get to the easy mode...since you dont actually "select" you have to die 3 times on the 1st level.
NummNutts @ Apr 22nd 2008 9:01PM
Point is I don't want the easy mode. I want at least hard mode; very hard would be even better.
OptimumEDGE @ Apr 22nd 2008 6:46PM
I've been hearing rumors an HD (Blu-ray) calibration disk from AVIA is due out soon.
As for what's available right now, you can checkout http://www.lagom.nl/lcd-test/ & http://www.tvblink.com/
=)
Bill @ Apr 22nd 2008 6:59PM
My guess regarding master tracks would be basically: they'd have to pay the original artist performance royalties. If they re-record the tracks they just use studio musicians who get paid a one time salary for their performance.
DemonGSides @ Apr 23rd 2008 1:05AM
Or more likely, the people who are making the game play the song.
That Fuzzy Bastard @ Apr 23rd 2008 1:52AM
Re: Master tracks
It could also be a problem of finding the original masters. For a Rock Band song, they need the original vocal, guitar, bass, drums, and other effects all on separate tracks (so they can be taken out when you miss a note). And for a lot of songs, those masters are just plain lost. Sometimes many songs on an album will have all the individual tracks availalbe, but another one won't be (that's why we didn't get the last song on Boston's first album).
Oh, and guys? I think M. Cooper was asking about the FPS Black, not Ninja Gaiden Black.
James @ Apr 23rd 2008 11:35AM
I'm pretty sure that in the "Black" question, "NG2" = "Ninja Gaiden 2".
Cal @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:03PM
Just do a google search for HDTV calibration images, display them on your 360 and start tuning
xenocidic @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:05PM
Blasphemy. GTA IV is GOTY '08
murph @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:12PM
Chu Chu Rocket 4 XBLA ASAP OK THX.
peacefuloutrage @ Apr 23rd 2008 9:12AM
Hell freakin' yes!!! With the puzzle editor and XBL multiplayer.
Matter @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:17PM
Actually for the Master Tracks, sometimes they are unable to use them because they simply do not exist anymore. Either damaged, stolen or lost.
So in order to get a master track often times the only way is to get it re-recorded by a cover band. If the master tracks of a band that has broken up, or someone has died in then obviously this is the only way to go.
You can read about more of it hear with an interview with Rock Bands audio director.
http://multiplayerblog.mtv.com/2007/11/05/rock-band-audio-director-on-master-tapes-bumping-into-guitar-hero-iii-and-dlc-part-2-of-2/
Mike @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:47PM
I used to work in music, and the official rock band word on missing master tracks sounds like a cover up to me. I very rarely heard of master tracks going missing with the exception of the rare instance where the place they were stored caught fire or suffered from some other natural disaster.
I suspect the actual reason comes down to money, and licensing agreements. I suspect we haven't seen full albums in rock band yet because the record labels have been trying to get a little more money out of harmonix. Not because the master tracks for the bands they want to use have gone mysteriously missing.
webster1990 @ Apr 22nd 2008 8:43PM
yeah, isn't this why they got the sex pistols to re-record for GHIII?
it makes complete sense.
Matter @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:18PM
Horrible grammar FTL I know. :) I'm at work so i had to type fast!
rookie.of.the.year @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:33PM
Master tracks are required for the GH songs so they can cut and splice the guitar track (so it doesn't play when you fudge a note for example). They have to use covers if master tracks aren't available (too expensive, already mixed/no way to seperate the guitar track, or if they simply don't exist) or I guess if the master track would be too expensive.
Mike @ Apr 22nd 2008 7:41PM
let me try and shed a little light on the rock band / gh dlc issue.
The short answer here is that covers are cheaper.
The long answer? Well, regardless of who recorded the track, the copyright holder (record label in most cases) requires a royalty be paid for each instance of a track you sell - usually pennies on the dollar - rarely more than fifteen cents/instance. That royalty fee goes up when you are licensing the master track as recorded by the original artist - usually putting it somewhere in the thirty cents per instance neighborhood. So, what mtv games, activision, harmonix, and konami have all settled on doing is spending the money to license the song itself, and paying a cover band a one time fee (if I had to guess, around 3k) to perform the track as a "work for hire" recording. That way, instead of paying ongoing royalties on the performance of the track by the original artist, they're only paying royalties on the track itself, and the performance is covered by the one time "work for hire" fee.
I used to work in music - I'm not just talking out of my ass.
andrew @ Apr 22nd 2008 8:03PM
Jet Set Radio on my 360 would be a creme dream.
Jake \\\ @ Apr 22nd 2008 8:40PM
Hey guys, sorry to rain on your parade, but the Dreamcast used Sega's proprietary GD-ROM format, which contained 1GB of data. In other words it's not a CD/DVD, and can't be read by the 360. Would be awesome if they could be though.
webster1990 @ Apr 22nd 2008 8:41PM
mmmm is there some plan to bring back "spiffy" that i am not aware of, because i am totally up for it.
Delgado @ Apr 22nd 2008 8:51PM
Hey guys, I am finishing up a Digital Media Law class this semester and I can probably help clear up a little bit of confusion on the first question.
It is a little more complicated that what I'm about to tell you, but essentially when you register for a Copyright, it isn't just cut and dry one copyright and you're done. If you wrote the song, that is a whole different copyright you would file than if you recorded the song. Pretty much that is what GH and RB have to fiddle with - the differences in the two. If the song is a cover, then they obtained the rights to use the song from the writer. If it is the full fledged song, they obtained both the rights, along with performance and display rights.
A good example is how most shitty pop music performed by these girls who can't sing (and even ones who can) isn't actually written by the "artists" themselves. I can guarantee you that 98% of Billboards top 100 were written and recorded by two entirely separate entities.
Also there is a difference between performance and display, and whether or not it is digital, but that goes into much more detail then I think the answer requires.
Delgado @ Apr 22nd 2008 9:05PM
Sorry, didn't totally finish up my explanation.
So, with the two differences: the copyright for the writing of the song is what you call compulsory licensing, because the artist has no say in who buys the copyright. Thus, anyone can license the rights to the writing of a song through (3) different agencies.
The copyright for the performance of a song is different - the artist has a say in it. With the first GH game, no one knew if it was a good use of their song and many were reluctant to license their performance rights - thus, many covers were in GH I. Now if you look at the subsequent games, more artists learned that the exposure they got was well worth the licensing, so more original recordings were used.
There are obviously some other reasons that come into play, but generally yeah...
Neuromancer @ Apr 22nd 2008 9:17PM
By the way I would buy Soul Calibur 1 as an Xbox Live Arcade game, hop to Namco! (But don't try to back fill Yoda into it.)
Boff @ Apr 23rd 2008 5:40AM
I use DVE (Digital Video Essentials) for calibration of my telly and projector.
peacefuloutrage @ Apr 23rd 2008 9:12AM
@Trevor
I bought a Datel Xport. Even though the files are named with hex, it does back up your old HDD. You can even import you old xbox games saves from a memory card. It used to be more popluar because people would "share" game saves until one of the system updates stopped all of that, but if you want to back up your own files, you should be fine.
SaFt @ Apr 23rd 2008 4:20PM
Also regarding the Dreamcast question. The Dreamcast used GD-ROMs and not CD-Roms or DvD-Roms. So Runing old DC games in the 360 is a no no.
TurboFool @ Apr 23rd 2008 2:32PM
Anyone else remember the pre-Xbox rumors that Microsoft had worked out a deal with Sega to build Dreamcast-game compatibility into the Xbox?