X3F Impressions: Lips review

Announced during E3 with the glitz and excess of a live performance by Welsh singer Duffy, it was obvious that Lips was Microsoft's attempt to create a music platform for the Xbox that would lure in the same gaming crowd as Sony's SingStar. With the promise of karaoke party fun, high tech motion controlled microphones and images of walking lips seared into our brains, we took Microsoft's Lips for a musical romp. Click towards the break to read our impressions.
Marketed as the party gamer's best friend, Lips is just that, a musical experience that is best shared with a group of friends who aren't afraid to sing out loud and dance on stage in the living room like the singer they've always
wanted to be. The point is simple, sing to the music karaoke-style and try to match your pitch with the lyrics that scroll on screen. Though, with Lips, you'll also be moving, because the game includes two wireless microphones that are motion controlled. This means that in order to score bonus multipliers, you'll have to wave the mic to the tune. Actually, we'd be willing to admit that the microphone hardware is the single best component of Lips. They're sleek, they light up to the music and (once one figures out how to sync the buggers to the console) are quite responsive to both vocal input and motion controls.Tucked inside Lips is a bunch of party friendly features including the ability to create playlists, a jukebox mode that pumps out the tunes at random, and cooperative singing. There are even activities that allow those who aren't physically singing to grab a 360 controller and add musical sound effects (including cowbell) to the musical performance. For the competitive folks, Lips includes a few battle modes as well as a versus mutliplayer mode where two players go head to head in a sing off to score the most points.
Speaking of scoring, during the course of a song, there are a few different medals based on skills that add to your score (pitch, performance, etc.), points for actually singing the correct note and a multiplier that works similar to "overdrive" in Rock Band. When enough of the singing meter is filled up, a simple microphone gesture will activate the game's "Star Stream".
Looking to the music, we're satisfied with the offering knowing that Lips aims to be as mainstream as possible by including popular tracks from various genres. Music from Avril Lavigne, Coldplay, Nirvana, Weezer, John Denver and Young MC are all there among others. The bad news is that Lips only ships with 40 tracks, which may be the game's biggest negative in terms of overall value. True, additional DLC can be purchased off the Marketplace for $2 a track, but an additional 20 tracks on disc would have definitely helped with Lips' value proposition. Oh, and as far as the game's touted "add your own music" feature ... well, it's garbage. You can only import non-DRM tracks from your iPod or 360 HDD and the karaoke experience is just not there. Imported music doesn't include any unique videos, there are no lyrics and the scoring system awards points just making a sound into the mic. We really don't see any point to importing music other than for those who get enjoyment from hearing their singing voice boomed through the television speakers.(click to embiggen)
As far as Lips living up to being a party game that'll get people moving, we'd say it's successful at that. But the trouble we have with Lips is how much value you get for your $69.99. There are two beautifully crafted wireless microphones, but the game's setlist is minimal and the song import feature is gimped. We have other Lips gripes (music videos aren't displayed in HD and you can't toggle how the lyrics are displayed), but in general it's a well thought out singing experience. Bottom line, if you're attracted to the Lips-style music offerings, are known as the party gamer in your social circle, have the cash to buy new music and the time to wait for MS to roll out enough content to make it an official music platform, then Lips just might be for you. If that doesn't describe you and you're okay with more rock influenced tracks, we'd probably recommend going with Rock Band or World Tour instead. Then again, they don't have wireless microphones that light up.









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
DBoyFlex @ Dec 1st 2008 11:20AM
To me, Rock Band is the real deal. Why? You can sing, you can play guitar, you can drum. The game has limitless DLC, and if you want to only sing, you can buy the game and use any usb mic or even the regular headset. Sure, lips may have fancy mics, but RB (maybe GH WT, I have not played it) is (seems to be) an all around more versatile game. Could be wrong, but I would rather have my custom rocker on screen rather than a bunch of real graphics of little boys of questionable gender orientation. IMO.
Perno @ Dec 1st 2008 12:39PM
I enjoy Rock Band more too, but I had a party a couple weeks ago and had some neighbors over. The female neighbor LOVES karaoke so she was psyched to sing while we all played, but we couldn't find a song that she knew any words to, so it was a struggle. I know the words go across the screen, but you still have to know how the song goes to sing the song properly, and she didn't know any of the songs. She's a 26 year old that's just into country and some older stuff...so at least Lips would have something for a situation like mine.
DBoyFlex @ Dec 1st 2008 12:42PM
Right, plus RB does not allow for multiplayer singing, so their are pros and cons, some one works for, some the other. For me though, RB is it. Plus I am not a huge singing fan. I use that feature in RB mainly for 4 person play.
Phizzy @ Dec 1st 2008 2:29PM
Rock Band does allow multiplayer singing. You just haven't tried it, have you?
DBoyFlex @ Dec 1st 2008 2:32PM
No, I have not. Apparently there is more to discover in RB. Where is that mode? Like I said, I do not sing much, hence I do not know much about that aspect, but anyways, how do you do it?
Mike @ Dec 1st 2008 11:33AM
I put it on my Christmas list, banking on Harmonix eventually patching in support for the mics in Rock Band 2.
Deezul @ Dec 1st 2008 11:38AM
I paid $60 earlier this year for American Idol; and you can find it now for $30. I think I wait for lips to be $30 or $40 before I pick it up. I'd much rather drop the $60 on the wireless Mad Catz Rock Band mike, since it has joystick controls on it and you don't need another controller.
HazyCloud @ Dec 1st 2008 12:07PM
The Mad Catz mic isn't wireless. It's wired with a controller stuffed in it. Handy, but the RB forums have stated the mics put out crappy audio.
If HMX makes LIPS work, good deal. If not, I'll be buying the Logitech wireless mic later this month for Rock Band.
Deezul @ Dec 1st 2008 12:40PM
Opps, you're right. Guess I'll just buy the fog and light kit for the "controller" for the microphone...
HazyCloud @ Dec 1st 2008 12:45PM
Yeah the fog kit is going on my Christmas list. I would like to try it out and test it, but I don't want to drop the 100 on it.
ROb @ Dec 1st 2008 12:12PM
We just bought Lips over the weekend, and it's a decent game as far as karaoke games go. Unfortunately, it's not very "party oriented" for how much they're pushing it as a party game!
My main gripe is that it doesn't have Any of the party-features Karaoke Revolution has offered in the past - it seems designed for only 2 people! No options for many people to compete, no multiple couple scoring, no choose-a-set-list-with-the-last-one-random type of fun that other party singing games offer. So weird!
So Lips is decent for 2 people and that's about all. Larger groups can still have fun, but there's no "game" in "party game" for groups; just karaoke.
darkdan @ Dec 1st 2008 12:12PM
I bought this game and I'm happy to say that you can play DRM tracks that you've purchased from the Zune store! (Yeah, I know, you're still paying Micro$oft - but it makes sense, since they can control their own DRM, but they can't help what Apple does to keep the music out of our Xboxes, right?)
robotoid @ Dec 1st 2008 12:23PM
yeah, but who really buys music from the zune marketplace.
who really has a zune in the first place, even.
Tony @ Dec 1st 2008 12:36PM
I think at least a couple million people now. They're not totally ignored lol.
But anyway, most things on the Zune marketplace don't have DRM anymore anyway.
ZenGaijin @ Dec 1st 2008 1:12PM
http://social.zune.net/member/Z3nGaijin
Quite a few of us
OrionnoirO @ Dec 1st 2008 7:17PM
Exactly...
http://social.zune.net/member/OrionnoirO
Actually more and more people are getting them that I know too, as they are seeing that MS doesnt just leave early adopters in the dust like Apple, and all subsequent updates and features filter back to the earlier models as the units use the same firmware. So, my Halo 3 LE Zune Gen1 still works great and has all the latest features, except the touch-wheel of course as that is a hardware change.
refinedsugar @ Dec 1st 2008 3:38PM
If there's a lesson to be learned from the PS3 Singstar experience, it's don't buy unless you know they are going to deliver satisfying DLC on a consistent basis.
J.R. @ Dec 1st 2008 4:07PM
@DBoyFlex:
I don't think anyone answered your question. In Rock Band 1&2, you can have a battle between two people with the same instument (2 guitars or 2 drum kits or 2 microphones). The modes are called Score Duel (both people play identical tracks, top score wins) and Tug Of War (players take turn playing sections, top score wins). It's extremely fun, especially with the drums and microphone duels.
dangcucu @ Dec 1st 2008 6:19PM
i have Lips & we loved it. i use the songs from my zune & my wife's ipod & it works just fine though you have to always have it plugged to the box for it to work. as karaoke goes i like this game over RB; KR as you can hear your voice best over everything. in RB i feel it gets drowned out. *P.S. my xbox has the RRoD for the 2nd time... so now Lips, GOW2, Burnout for awhile...
Khaled @ Dec 1st 2008 6:54PM
WOW that screen looks really close to SingStar
shuref00t @ Dec 1st 2008 7:09PM
I'd be interested in a X3F Lips Giveaway... I mean, for my girlfriend, of course! =oP
chad @ Dec 21st 2008 3:27PM
Ok - I bought Lips a couple of weeks ago and tried to get it to work tonight but I can't seem to get the microphones synced up with the console - any ideas? Am I missing something? Read and re-read the instructions but for the life of me it's not working!
Please help - a distressed person at a party with no karaoke...